Simple Trolling for Lake Trout

We're out here on Lake Ontario looking for that Lake Trout bite. Antonio and I are going to flat line troll today - that's it, no fancy tech. Snap on a lure and start trolling. Our lure of choice for the day is the deep-driving American Smelt crankbait. I went with the silver-blue, and Antonio went with the straight silver.

Which one do you think struck first?